Controversy Erupts Over Harbour Court’s Proposed Makeover

Harbour Court, a notorious Dublin laneway recently shut down due to safety concerns, might reopen with a makeover. Two city councillors have sparked controversy by proposing a plan to re-open the alley with murals, better lighting, and even an addiction helpline.

(Also read John Bishop’s ‘Back At It’ Tour Comes to Dublin for 2 Days.)

Harbour Court – From “Public Toilet” to Public Art?

Just last month, the council voted to close the lane, following complaints from nearby businesses about anti-social behaviour, drug use, and dumping. However, some now suggest this approach might be too drastic. 

A multifaceted plan for reopening the laneway was put out by Sinn Féin council member Janice Boylan and independent council member Christy Burke. 

Their plan includes: 

• Brightening the space: Improved lighting to deter negative activity.
• Commissioning murals to make the area more visually appealing.
• Support for addiction: Working with the HSE to offer tools to people who are addicted.
• Increased patrols: Working with Gardai to enhance security in the area. 

This proposal has divided opinions. However, Green Party councillor Janet Horner welcomes the proposal, emphasising the importance of keeping public spaces open. Independent Cieran Perry, who initially supported the closure, can explore solutions. 

Others, like Fine Gael’s Ray McAdam, argue it’s too soon to reconsider, citing strong concerns from businesses and the need for deeper stakeholder engagement. 

Independent councillor Nial Ring, initially supportive of the closure, finds the reopening plan “horrible,” while Independent Cieran Perry, who reluctantly backed the closure, sees no harm in exploring the options. 

The council’s city centre manager, Frank Lambe, acknowledged the proposal but reiterated that the current closure decision stands. Ultimately, the fate of Harbour Court rests on further discussion and agreement within the council, balancing the needs of businesses and residents with the value of accessible public spaces. 

This potential U-turn highlights the complex challenges of balancing public safety with accessibility in urban spaces. Whether murals and outreach programs can create a safer and more welcoming Harbour Court remains to be seen. The council’s engagement with stakeholders and potential future discussions will reveal which vision for this laneway will prevail.